Making Omnichannel Marketing Work When Your Customers Don’t Think in Channels
Mayank Patel
May 22, 2025
4 min read
Last updated May 22, 2025
Table of Contents
Why Traditional Channel-Based Thinking Fails
What Customers Actually Expect
Fix Your Data Layer
Mapping the Journey (for Real This Time)
Rethinking Campaign Design
Getting Teams to Work Like Journeys, Not Channels
Rethinking Attribution and ROI
Small Steps to Start
Serve Behavior, Not Channels
Share
Contact Us
Most ecommerce and retail teams still build marketing around channels. You have a team for paid search. Another for email. One for social. Someone else manages in-store promotions. These teams run in parallel, often optimizing in isolation.
But here’s the disconnect: your customer doesn’t think in channels. They remember experiences.
They might click an Instagram ad, browse on mobile, get an abandoned cart email, and walk into a store—all before buying. If any part of that journey feels inconsistent or disjointed, you lose trust, momentum, and conversion.
Omnichannel marketing isn’t just about being present everywhere. It’s about stitching together a journey that feels like one brand, not a bunch of disconnected touchpoints. And that requires a shift in mindset, data infrastructure, team alignment, and execution.
In this guide, we’ll break down the hard truths, common traps, and operational playbooks for DTC and retail brands that want to build omnichannel strategies that actually reflect how customers behave.
1. Why Traditional Channel-Based Thinking Fails
Most DTC and retail marketing orgs default to channel-based structures because they make budgeting cleaner and reporting easier to slice. But that operational clarity comes at the cost of customer experience. This model reinforces silos, creates internal competition, and fractures the journey your customer actually takes.
Symptoms of Channel-Centric Marketing:
Campaign KPIs that compete rather than collaborate (e.g., paid search stealing credit from email)
Repetitive or conflicting messaging across touchpoints
Siloed customer data that prevents unified personalization
Gaps in attribution leading to wasted ad spend or under-funded programs
In reality, customers behave like this:
Discover a product on TikTok
Visit your site and browse categories
Forget, then get retargeted via Google Display
Read reviews via a third-party app
Get an SMS promo 3 days later
Purchase through the app, not the site
Channel-focused teams treat each of those interactions as a separate campaign. But the customer sees one brand. That gap between perception and execution is where revenue gets lost.
2. What Customers Actually Expect
Today’s shoppers don’t demand omnichannel. They assume it’s the bare minimum—especially younger cohorts like Gen Z. They expect a seamless, fluid experience—whether they’re on their phone, walking into your store, or responding to an email offer—because that’s how they live every day:
Device switching is natural (start on mobile, checkout on desktop)
If your message, offer, or experience doesn’t match where they are in the moment, it feels like friction. And friction breaks the funnel.
3. Fix Your Data Layer
Omnichannel marketing without a unified data foundation is like running a relay with blindfolded teammates—your message might get passed along, but not to the right person, at the right time, or in a way that makes sense. Without tying identities, behaviors, and engagements together across touchpoints, you're investing in experiences your customer can't connect. And if you’re still figuring out if you need a CDP, CRM, or DMP? This breakdown explains what to use to build a unified customer view.
What Needs to Be Unified:
Customer profiles across devices, sessions, and stores
Behavioral data from web, app, email, SMS, ads, POS
Order history and lifetime value
Engagement signals (clicks, opens, site searches, etc.)
You don’t need a giant enterprise CDP to get started. But you do need:
Clear IDs: Consistent identifiers across tools (email, phone, customer ID)
Event tracking: Standardized events across platforms (viewed product, added to cart, etc.)
Accessible data: Marketers should be able to query and act on data without waiting on devs
If your systems can’t recognize that someone who clicked your email is the same person who visited your store last week, you're not ready for omnichannel.
4. Mapping the Journey (for Real This Time)
Most journey maps are shallow. They focus on ideal states or internal workflows, not messy real-world behavior—the kind that involves indecision, device switching, last-minute store visits, and moments of distraction.
These sanitized maps look good in decks but fail to reflect how customers actually move, pause, bounce, return, and convert. To be useful, a journey map needs to account for friction, context shifts, and the nonlinear way intent builds over time.
Here’s how to actually map an omnichannel journey:
Start with data, not assumptions: Look at session drop-offs, entry points, and repeat visits
Plot key decision points: When does consideration peak? Where does intent show up
Identify channel overlaps: Are you retargeting people with the same product they bought last week?
Audit content and messaging: Is the product copy the same on your email and PDP? Also, don’t overlook how users search. Optimizing your site search experience can eliminate friction right at the decision point. Map failure points: Where do people bounce? Where do they repeat actions?
5. Rethinking Campaign Design
Omnichannel campaigns need to follow the customer, not the calendar. That means anchoring your messaging to signals, not schedules. If someone is actively comparing products or has just engaged with a PDP, a discount might be relevant now—not next week when the promo is scheduled.
If a loyal customer hasn't bought in 90 days, a retention touchpoint shouldn't wait for the next quarterly push. The rhythm of your campaign should match the pace of customer behavior, not the cadence of your internal marketing calendar.
Channel-first: Email blast + Facebook ads during a weekend sale
Omnichannel: Segment high-LTV buyers who browsed but didn’t buy in the past week. Show personalized discount in email. Follow up with dynamic product ads or explore strategies that reduce the steps to conversion altogether—like zero-click PDPs that bring conversion forward in the funnel. Suppress people who already purchased from the campaign.
6. Getting Teams to Work Like Journeys, Not Channels
Team structure is a silent killer of omnichannel.
When paid, email, CX, and retail store ops don’t share goals or workflows, customer journeys break—often in invisible ways. A customer might get retargeted with a product they already bought in-store. Or receive a discount code via email, only to find store staff unaware of it.
These aren’t just coordination errors; they’re trust-breakers. Without shared context, the handoffs between teams create friction that customers feel, even if they can't articulate it. Omnichannel success depends on behind-the-scenes alignment that removes those seams.
Tactics That Help:
Shared KPIs: Track campaign impact across email, ads, and site engagement
Cross-functional squads: Build temporary teams around goals (e.g., reduce cart abandonment)
Shared calendars and retros: Regular meetings where teams discuss journey outcomes, not just channel wins
Unified briefs: When planning a campaign, everyone gets the same context and customer insights
7. Rethinking Attribution and ROI
Old attribution models break under omnichannel. Last-touch undervalues upper funnel work like awareness campaigns, influencer exposure, or early content engagement. First-touch attribution, meanwhile, can miss the nuance of sustained influence or mid-funnel nurturing. In a world where customers touch five or more surfaces before converting, these binary models obscure rather than clarify how value is actually created across the journey.
What to track instead:
Time-to-conversion by journey type
Channel assist rates
Repeat engagement before purchase
Cross-channel campaign impact
Incrementality testing for key journeys
Even if you don’t have multi-touch attribution software, you can:
Run holdout groups
Compare cohorts with/without specific channel exposure
One journey: Focus on abandoned carts or winback. These are high-intent, high-friction scenarios where every missed touchpoint costs revenue. Start with a clear narrative: someone abandoned a product—what would it take to bring them back?
Two channels: Coordinate email and paid social. Email gives you owned reach and rich personalization; paid social gives you scale and visual cues. Together, they form a basic but powerful retargeting loop.
Clear signals: Use behavior to trigger the next best action. Viewed a product but didn’t add to cart? Trigger a soft nudge. Added to cart but didn’t check out? Use urgency or social proof. Opened but didn’t click? Change the creative.
Simple rules: Start with rules like: If they click X, suppress Y for 3 days; if they buy, stop A and trigger a thank-you flow; if no activity for 7 days, move to winback. Over time, these rules can evolve into automated journeys, but even basic logic beats static blasts.
Test. Refine. Expand.
You’re not building omnichannel for the buzzword. You’re building it because your customers already live that way.
The omnichannel challenge isn’t about complexity. It’s about alignment. Align your systems to reflect real customer behavior. Align your teams around journeys. Align your measurement around progress, not vanity metrics. Your customers don’t think in channels. The more your marketing mirrors that reality, the more likely they are to convert, return, and advocate.
Mayank Patel
CEO
Mayank Patel is an accomplished software engineer and entrepreneur with over 10 years of experience in the industry. He holds a B.Tech in Computer Engineering, earned in 2013.
Your customers aren’t just shopping from one place. They're browsing on Instagram, price-checking on mobile, ordering on desktop, and picking up in-store. A headless architecture gives you the agility to serve these touchpoints from a unified backend, crucial when rethinking retail strategy for Gen Z.
2. Developer Velocity
With a decoupled frontend, your dev team isn’t stuck waiting on backend releases just to ship UI changes. Faster iteration, better UX testing, fewer bottlenecks.
3. Composable Commerce
The "best-of-breed" approach is winning. MedusaJS plays nicely with other services—whether that’s Stripe for payments, Algolia for search, or custom-built fulfillment logic. You're not locked into a platform’s opinionated add-ons.
MedusaJS vs. Shopify vs. Magento vs. CommerceTools
Let’s break down how Medusa stacks up against the giants.
MedusaJS
Shopify
Magento (Adobe Commerce)
CommerceTools
Open Source
Yes
No
Yes (limited)
No
Headless
Fully
Limited (Hydrogen)
Possible but messy
Fully
Custom Workflows
High flexibility
Limited to apps
Complex
High flexibility
Frontend Agnostic
Yes
Shopify Liquid/Hydrogen
Yes
Yes
Pricing
Free
Subscription + fees
License + hosting
Expensive enterprise tiers
Key Features That Set MedusaJS Apart
MedusaJS stands out by blending developer-friendly flexibility with enterprise-grade features. Its modular design, headless capabilities, and rich ecosystem uniquely position it as a scalable, adaptable alternative to traditional ecommerce platforms. Here's how these distinguishing characteristics offer clear advantages to developers and businesses alike:
Modular & Composable Architecture
Medusa takes a modular approach from the ground up. Instead of one big monolith, you get decoupled Commerce Modules—cart, products, orders, and more—that work independently. You can pick what you need, drop in your own logic, or scale piece by piece. No core hacking required. It’s all built around clean abstractions that make customization straightforward and maintainable. Compared to rigid setups like Shopify or Magento, Medusa gives you room to build without bumping into platform limits.
Headless Flexibility (Frontend Agnostic)
Medusa is headless from day one. The frontend’s fully decoupled, so you’re free to use whatever framework you want—Next.js, Gatsby, or something custom. It’s all powered through Medusa’s REST APIs, which means your UI and backend can evolve independently. Frontend teams can move fast, test ideas, and fine-tune the user experience without touching backend logic. Consider simplifying your store’s homepage to further accelerate customer journeys. Compare that to Shopify’s tightly coupled setup—unless you’re on Shopify Plus, going headless is a workaround, not a feature.
Built-In Customization Framework
Customization isn’t an afterthought with Medusa—it’s the whole point. The framework’s built to be extended, tweaked, and tailored without diving into brittle hacks or rewriting the core. Want new data models? Custom APIs? Your own logic in the order flow? Medusa’s clean abstractions and plugin system make it all doable with minimal friction.
You get full control to shape the backend around your business, not the other way around. That’s a sharp contrast to most SaaS platforms, which force you into fixed features or awkward workarounds. Even open-source options like Magento can be a headache—customizing it often means wrestling with complex internals or bloated plugins. Medusa, on the other hand, keeps it lean and JavaScript-native, so any developer can jump in and build fast.
Rich Plugin & Integration Ecosystem
Medusa comes packed with a powerful plugin system and a growing library of integrations for the essentials—payments, CMS, search, analytics, fulfillment (learn how optimizing site search boosts conversions), you name it. Right out of the box, it plays well with Stripe, PayPal, Klarna, Adyen, Contentful, Algolia, and more. Thanks to its open architecture, plugging in new tools—whether it’s a CRM, shipping provider, or a custom internal service—is hassle-free.
Unlike Shopify, where you’re often juggling five apps (and their fees) just to cover basic features, Medusa keeps things clean. Many capabilities are built-in or available as lightweight plugins, so you skip the app clutter and maintenance overhead. Plus, with full control of your stack, you can build your own plugins or tap into what the Medusa community has already shipped—like a ready-to-use multi-vendor marketplace extension. It’s modular commerce that doesn’t get in your way.
Freedom in Payment & Shipping Choices
Medusa doesn’t play gatekeeper when it comes to payments. It supports top gateways like Stripe and PayPal out of the box—and because it’s open source, you can hook in any provider you want, including regional or niche options. No extra fees, no platform lock-in. That’s a big departure from Shopify, which nudges you toward Shopify Payments and charges transaction fees (up to 2%) if you go outside the walled garden.
With Medusa, you get full control over how payments work. Same goes for shipping and fulfillment—plug in whatever carriers or logistics services make sense for your business, no strings attached. It’s the kind of flexibility you'd expect from enterprise tools like CommerceTools, but without the price tag or complex setup. Thanks to Medusa’s plugin system and open APIs, you can pick the best tools for the job—payments, shipping, tax, you name it—and integrate them cleanly into your stack.
Developer-Friendly & Modern Tech Stack
Medusa runs on a modern Node.js and TypeScript stack, making it instantly more approachable for most dev teams than the legacy PHP or proprietary setups you’ll find in Magento or Shopify. It’s built with a developer-first mindset—commerce features are ready to go, but nothing’s locked down. You can customize, extend, or swap logic without wrestling with the internals.
Medusa’s gained traction fast—it’s now the most popular JavaScript-based ecommerce project on GitHub, hitting 10K+ stars shortly after launch. That momentum brings an active community, plenty of plugins, and a fast pace of innovation. Compared to proprietary platforms that guard their source or require costly certifications just to customize deeply, Medusa stays open and hack-free. You get to build with familiar tools, avoid workarounds, and keep your codebase clean and maintainable over the long haul.
Robust Core Features (No Trade-off for Flexibility)
Even with its focus on flexibility, Medusa ships with a full-featured core that stacks up well against the big names. Right out of the box, you get everything you need—product catalog, cart and checkout, orders, customer accounts, discounts, and more.
And it doesn’t stop at the basics. Medusa includes advanced features that other platforms often charge extra for: built-in Return Merchandise Authorization (RMA) flows for returns and exchanges, native multi-currency and multi-region support, and a powerful discount engine you can fully tailor.
There’s also an admin dashboard included—clean, intuitive, and customizable. Operators can manage products, orders, and customers without touching code, and developers can extend the UI with custom widgets or pages. It’s a strong foundation that saves teams from rebuilding common features from scratch, while still letting them reshape any part of the stack.
That combo—robust out-of-the-box functionality plus full extensibility—is where Medusa really stands apart. Shopify makes it easy to start but leans heavily on third-party apps for advanced features. Magento’s packed with features but is famously tough to modify. Medusa gives you both: a ready-to-run engine you can take apart and rebuild to fit your exact needs.
Business-Level Benefits
Beyond technical superiority, MedusaJS delivers substantial business-level advantages. Its open-source, offers better control, and accelerates market entry and more:
Open-Source & Cost Efficiency
Medusa is 100% open source and free under the MIT license—no license fees, no per-transaction charges, no strings attached. That’s a major win over platforms like Shopify, which not only charge monthly fees but also take a cut of your revenue if you use third-party payments. CommerceTools? Enterprise pricing from day one. Medusa flips that script: everything in the core—framework, modules, advanced features—is free to use and self-host.
You can run it on your own infra at zero cost, or opt into Medusa’s hosted cloud if you want managed services. Either way, you’re not locked into pricey contracts or forced upgrades. There are no transaction fees, no revenue shares—so merchants keep more of what they earn. Features like multi-region support or promo engines aren’t gated behind a paywall either. Compare that to Shopify, where you need add-ons for complex needs, or Magento, where the “free” version lacks enterprise-grade capabilities unless you pony up for Adobe Commerce.
Full Ownership & No Vendor Lock-In
With Medusa, you own it all—your stack, your data, your roadmap. The platform is open source and self-hosted (or cloud-hosted on your terms), so you're never stuck waiting on a vendor or boxed in by someone else’s priorities.
Medusa’s philosophy is simple: merchants should control the full user experience and shape the platform around their needs—not the other way around. That’s a sharp contrast to SaaS platforms like Shopify or CommerceTools, where your freedom is limited by platform policies, app store approvals, and proprietary roadmaps.
The Medusa team makes the point clearly: SaaS is fine for getting started, but as your business grows and your needs get specific, those constraints start to hurt. Medusa’s built as a long-term foundation—one that grows with you and doesn’t require a painful replatform down the line.
You’re also protected from platform churn. Shopify can pull apps without warning, leaving you scrambling. With Medusa, everything critical lives in your codebase. And even if the core company ever changes course, the open-source nature and growing community ensure you’re never left stranded.
Fast Time-to-Market
Medusa doesn’t just give you flexibility—it helps you move fast, too. With starter templates for everything from D2C retail (Next.js) to B2B and Gatsby storefronts, you can launch a working store in minutes. The backend’s preloaded with essentials like product catalogs, carts, orders, and integrations, so your team skips the boilerplate and gets right to what matters: building the custom features that set your business apart.
Medusa’s promise to “launch in minutes” isn’t just marketing—it’s built into the developer experience. You get SaaS-level speed to market with the freedom of a fully customizable platform. Shopify is fast, but you’re stuck inside its sandbox. Legacy open-source platforms are flexible, but slow to get off the ground. Medusa hits the sweet spot.
You can start with solid building blocks and scale up from there—no need to choose between shipping quickly and staying flexible. One team put it best: Medusa “enabled us to construct modules at any scale and create unique products much faster than traditional solutions would allow.” That kind of agility pays off—whether you’re launching a flash-sale site, expanding into new regions, or spinning up a new mobile app. It's also ideal for brands needing to rapidly launch SKUs without historical data, testing product-market fit fast.
Scalable & Future-Proof for Growth
Medusa is built to scale—no matter your size. Whether you’re a startup or pushing over $100M in annual GMV, the platform is designed to grow with you. There are no arbitrary limits, licensing gates, or feature walls.
Medusa’s modular architecture—especially with Medusa 2.0 breaking services into independent components—means you can scale vertically or horizontally as needed. VeVe, one of Medusa’s users, has handled thousands of requests per second using just the cart module—no sweat.
Performance and flexibility are baked in. Unlike Magento, which can get bloated fast on small projects, Medusa stays lean when you need it to and stretches to meet enterprise demands with added resources or services. It’s efficient when you're small and powerful when you’re big. This flexibility reduces uncertainty and allows you to make decisions based on probability rather than costly guesses.
That scalability also means you’re future-proofed. If your business shifts direction—new regions, new models, new channels—you don’t need to replatform. Medusa’s open architecture lets you adapt and extend freely. It’s API-first like CommerceTools, but with full transparency and control over every layer.
Supports Unique Business Models and Complete Custom Experiences
Medusa’s biggest edge? You’re free to build commerce your way. Whether it’s subscriptions, multi-vendor marketplaces, B2B workflows, or something entirely off the beaten path, Medusa gives you the tools to make it happen. Its modular architecture lets you inject custom logic, define new resource types, and plug in external systems like ERPs or pricing engines, all without rewriting the core.
You’re not stuck with generic workflows like you are on Shopify or buried under Magento’s complexity. Need to support rental models, flash-sale events with virtual queues, or deeply personalized shopping flows? Medusa’s got your back. The docs even include recipes and guides to fast-track development for these use cases—whether you’re launching a marketplace, subscription engine, or something custom to your business.
Even the admin panel is yours to shape. You can extend it with custom views, widgets, and workflows to fit your internal ops. That kind of flexibility is usually reserved for enterprise platforms or fully custom builds, but Medusa brings it to the open-source world—without the overhead.
Real-World Use Cases for DTC and Retail Teams
So what does all this look like in action? For DTC brands and retail teams juggling everything from inventory orchestration to multi-market storefronts, MedusaJS isn’t just a promising tool—it’s a practical enabler. Here’s how:
Launch Multiple Storefronts from a Single Backend
Running a US and EU site with slightly different pricing and promotions? MedusaJS supports multi-region setups natively.
Deep Product Customization
Need to handle bundles, build-your-own-box, or tiered subscription pricing? Medusa's flexible product and pricing engine makes it doable without hacks. Something that shoppers truly want.
Checkout UX Overhaul
Want a React checkout that doesn't feel like a clunky iframe? Medusa gives you the backend plumbing—build your own sleek, native UI—which can be critical if steady traffic isn’t converting as expected.
Integration with Existing Systems
Already have a PIM, ERP, or custom warehouse system? Medusa’s API-first design and event-driven hooks make integration straightforward.
Custom B2B Workflows
For ecommerce teams servicing B2B customers alongside DTC, Medusa’s flexibility makes it easy to implement workflows like bulk ordering, tiered pricing, account-based access, and invoice-based payments—all without needing a completely separate backend.
Flash Sale and Campaign Logic
Need to spin up a high-conversion flash sale landing page or campaign-specific checkout? Medusa’s event-driven system and modular API let you launch these quickly without disrupting the main storefront experience.
Medusa’s GitHub repo is very active. You’ll find a growing ecosystem of plugins and examples, plus active discussions in Discord and GitHub Issues.
Clear Focus on Ecommerce (Not Generic CMS)
Unlike Strapi or Directus, MedusaJS is purpose-built for ecommerce. The data models, workflows, and defaults all cater to commerce logic—not generic content.
Faster Time to MVP
Compared to building your own stack from scratch with Express or NestJS, Medusa gives you a powerful foundation with many ecommerce workflows already handled.
Common Concerns (And Why They’re Overblown)
"It’s not SaaS, so we have to host it."
True, but Docker + cloud hosting (Vercel, Railway, Render, etc.) makes setup trivial. Plus, you own the data and avoid revenue-based fees.
"What about security and PCI compliance?"
MedusaJS doesn’t store credit card info. You’ll use Stripe, PayPal, etc. for payments—same as with Shopify. You control the data boundary.
"Will it scale?"
It’s built for horizontal scaling. APIs, services, and plugins can all be distributed independently. You’re not tied to a single monolith.
Who Should Seriously Consider MedusaJS?
Emerging DTC brands looking to differentiate beyond Shopify themes.
Retail teams wanting a future-proof, API-first backend for multiple storefronts.
Technical ecommerce teams frustrated with the constraints of SaaS platforms.
Startups building commerce tools that need a flexible, commerce-ready backend.
If you’re betting on headless, composable commerce—MedusaJS is more than just viable. It’s arguably the most developer- and business-friendly starting point in the ecosystem today.
A “dumb” search box that offers no assistance is a wasted opportunity. Modern users expect autocomplete suggestions as they type. If your DTC site search lacks this, you force users to type full queries and guess keywords, increasing the chance of typos or mismatches.
Autocomplete not only speeds up the search process but also guides users by suggesting popular products or categories. For example, if a user types “dress”, a good autocomplete will drop down suggestions like “summer dress”, “red cocktail dress”, or specific product names. Without autocomplete, you miss the chance to steer customers to what they might be looking for.
Lesson: Implement an autocomplete feature that suggests relevant search terms, products, or even images as the user types.
Poor Handling of Synonyms and Misspellings
A very common mistake is relying on exact-match keyword search. If your search algorithm can’t interpret synonyms, plurals, or slight misspellings, customers will see those dreaded “No results found” pages far too often. For instance, a shopper might search for “sofa” and get zero results because your products are labeled “couch,” or they type “tshirt” and your catalog only matches “t-shirt.” Shoppers often use different words (or make typos) for the same intent.
Lesson: Ensure your search can tolerate spelling errors and recognize equivalent terms.
Even when search returns results, are they the right results? A common issue is poor relevance ranking – for example, a query for “organic shampoo” might return a long list where the top items aren’t even shampoo, or they’re irrelevant products that happen to contain one of the words. This often happens with basic search engines that sort by trivial criteria or don’t understand context. If users get a page of products that don’t match their intent, they will bounce.
Lesson: Don’t let your search be “dumb.” It should prioritize relevancy – taking into account product titles, descriptions, popularity, and user intent – rather than just doing a raw text match. If your analytics show users often refine their search or exit after seeing results, it’s a sign your relevancy algorithm needs improvement.
No “Zero Results” Fallback Plan
One of the worst dead-ends in ecommerce is a blank search results page that says “0 results for your query.” Often, this happens because of the issues above (typos, synonyms, etc.) or when the catalog truly doesn’t have what was searched. But many DTC sites make the mistake of leaving users at this dead end with no guidance.
Lesson: Never leave a zero-results page blank. At minimum, provide helpful suggestions like “Check your spelling or try a simpler term,” or display alternative products and categories. Better yet, proactively avoid zero results by implementing fuzzy matching (showing the closest matching items). If a term isn’t found, show popular products or offer to contact support. A “no results” page can even be turned into a merchandising opportunity by showcasing best-sellers or new arrivals so the session isn’t wasted.
Some DTC brands treat search results pages too simplistically – just a dump of items with no way to refine. If a user searches a broad term like “shoes” or “moisturizer,” they might get hundreds of results. Without the ability to narrow down (e.g. filter by size, color, price, category) or sort (by relevance, price, popularity), the shopper can get overwhelmed.
Lesson: Treat your search results page like a mini category page – include facet filters (brand, category, price range, attributes) and sorting controls. This allows shoppers to drill down to exactly what they want if the initial result set is too broad. It’s especially essential for DTC verticals like fashion (think filters for size, style, color) and electronics (filters for specs, features).
Slow Search Performance
If a shopper types a query and your site takes several seconds to load results or suggestions, you’re introducing friction. Slow search responses often result from unoptimized databases or servers. Mobile users in particular might abandon if results don’t appear almost instantly.
Lesson: Optimize your search for speed. This might mean upgrading your search technology, indexing data for quicker lookup, or caching frequent queries. The goal should be to deliver results in a blink (under a second) so that users feel the search is responsive and reliable.
DTC brands that design a decent desktop search often drop the ball on mobile. If the search icon is hard to tap, or the results overlay is difficult to navigate on a phone screen, you’ll lose mobile shoppers (who are a huge portion of traffic). Mobile search needs to account for smaller screens and touch input. Additionally, because typing on mobile is prone to errors, error tolerance becomes even more critical.
Lesson: Make sure your internal search is fully mobile-optimized. This includes a prominent search icon, a fullscreen search interface that’s easy to read, big tap targets for suggestions, and robust autocorrect for fat-finger typos. You might also consider voice search input for mobile users as a convenience feature.
Not Analyzing Search Data
Finally, a strategic mistake many DTC teams make is failing to monitor and learn from site search analytics. Your internal search logs are a goldmine of customer intent data – they show exactly what users want, in their own words. If no one is looking at this data, you’re missing opportunities. For example, you might discover that dozens of people search for “gift card” on your site and you have none, or that a specific product is constantly searched (indicating high interest).
Lesson: Regularly review what users are searching for, which queries return zero results, and which searches lead to purchases. This will inform everything from adding new products (if there’s demand) to adjusting your search synonyms. It will also help you continuously improve the search experience –for instance, if you see many people search for “FAQ” or “shipping”, you might integrate content results or quick answers into the search.
Knowing the problems is half the battle. Now let’s focus on practical solutions. Here are concrete tactics DTC brands can implement to turn their internal site search into a conversion powerhouse:
Make the Search Bar Prominent and User-Friendly
Ensure the search field is impossible to miss on your site’s layout. Use a clear icon and consider a placeholder text like “Search products…” to invite usage. For mobile sites, put the search icon in the header on every page. The easier it is to start a search, the more people will use it.
This is a quick win: simply emphasizing the search bar on your homepage or landing pages can drive more engagement. Make sure the search box is also functional: allow submitting by pressing enter or tapping a search icon, and keep the text in the box after search (so users can refine their query without retyping it).
Implement Autocomplete and Query Suggestions
Add an autocomplete dropdown that appears as the user types in the search box. This should dynamically suggest likely search terms, product names, categories, or even display thumbnail previews of products. A rich autocomplete speeds up the process and guides users toward actual items you carry.
For example, if a user types “moisturizer”, the suggestions might include “moisturizer for oily skin”, specific product lines, or relevant content like “How to choose a moisturizer (Blog)”. This way, even if they don’t know the exact product name, the system helps them along. Autocomplete can also correct spelling mistakes on the fly (“Did you mean…”) before the user even hits enter. Given how many shoppers expect this feature, implementing it can significantly improve search success rates and reduce exits.
Build a Synonym Dictionary (and Use Fuzzy Matching)
To avoid zero-results situations, configure your search to handle synonyms, variations, and misspellings. Start by analyzing your search logs for queries that returned no results or poor results – often you’ll find common patterns (e.g., “tee” vs “t-shirt”, “laptop case” vs “notebook sleeve”).
Create a synonym dictionary mapping these terms to the ones your catalog uses. Many modern search platforms let you define synonyms (so that “couch” searches also match “sofa”, etc.). Additionally, enable fuzzy search or auto-correction to catch typographical errors. A user shouldn’t have to type a query perfectly to find what they need – if they type “iphon charger”, your search should reasonably assume they meant “iPhone charger” even if the spelling differs.
Optimize Relevance Ranking (Boost the Best Matches)
Improving the ranking logic of your search results is one of the most impactful changes you can make. Instead of a basic text match, use a ranking algorithm that factors in relevancy signals. These signals can include: keyword match (product title, description, tags), but also product popularity, conversion rate, in-stock status, and even personalization (more on that shortly).
For example, if someone searches for “running shoes”, your top results might be your best-selling running shoe styles (because popularity often correlates with what most shoppers want), rather than an obscure product that just has “running” in its description. Many DTC brands also choose to manually “pin” or boost certain results for key search terms – this is sometimes called search merchandising. For instance, you might always want your flagship product to appear first for a category search, or you might boost items that have higher margins.
Search optimization (sometimes termed “searchandising”) allows you to blend relevance with business goals. Audit some of your common searches – are the top results truly what a customer likely wanted? If not, adjust your search algorithm settings (or rules in your search tool) to promote more relevant or profitable items. Continually test and tweak relevance by watching search click-through rates and conversion rates. When relevance improves, conversions go up – shoppers find the right product faster and buy with less friction.
As mentioned in the mistakes, giving users the power to refine search results is very important, especially if you have a broad catalog. Implement a sidebar or top menu of filters on the search results page. Typical filters include things like category, brand, price range, size, color, ratings, etc., depending on your product vertical.
Also consider context-specific filters; for example, if someone searches “laptops,” show filters for screen size, RAM, etc., but if they search “running shoes,” show filters for shoe size, gender, and so on. In addition to filters, a sort-by dropdown (e.g. sort by price low-to-high, newest arrivals, customer rating) can help users reorganize results to their liking.
Providing these refinements significantly improves the chance that a shopper will find a product that fits their specific needs. Work with your development team or search provider to implement faceted navigation on the search results. Start with the most important attributes (the ones customers frequently care about) and add more as needed. Make sure the filters are relevant to the query context if possible (dynamic filtering).
Design for Zero Results (Always Offer Alternatives)
Despite your best efforts, there will be times when a search query doesn’t match any product exactly – maybe the item is out of stock or outside your offerings. Plan for this scenario. Instead of a blank “no results” page, design a helpful zero-results page that keeps the visitors engaged. Tactics for this include:
Show a message like “Sorry, we couldn’t find that. Here are some suggestions:”
Provide links to top-level categories or a site map (“Try these departments…”).
Display top-selling products or new arrivals (which might interest any shopper).
If you have a live chat or chatbot, prompt the user “Need help finding something?” on the no-results page.
Encourage a broader search: “Try searching for a more general term.” Perhaps even keep their query in the search box and allow them to edit it easily (so they don’t have to retype from scratch).
The goal is to turn a dead end into a detour that can still lead to a sale. Create a custom no-results component on your site. Populate it with a few product recommendations (popular items or those related to the query if possible), a search tips section, and a call-to-action like contacting support.
Once you start making these improvements, it’s important to treat site search as an ongoing, data-driven project. Set up tracking for search queries in your analytics (if you haven’t already via Google Analytics or similar) to capture metrics like: top search queries, frequency of searches, zero-result rates, search exit rates (people who leave after searching), etc. Use these insights to continuously tune your search.
For example, if “promo code” is a frequent search on your DTC site, that’s a hint to make your discount code or sale information easier to find (maybe create a dedicated page or FAQ that your search can surface). If a specific product is trending in searches, ensure it’s prominently featured. Also, identify queries with poor performance – if a high-volume search term has a low click-through or conversion rate, investigate why (maybe the results are irrelevant or there’s no satisfying result).
By iterating in this way, you create a feedback loop: better search → more conversions → more data to improve search further. Schedule a monthly (or bi-weekly) review of site search reports. Adjust your synonym list, add redirects or merchandising rules for oddball queries, and consider A/B testing changes (some advanced search platforms allow A/B testing different search algorithms or configurations).
Use Merchandising Rules (Searchandizing)
“Searchandizing” is the practice of merchandising within search results – essentially, customizing the outcome for business objectives. We touched on this in ranking optimization, but let’s emphasize specific tactics:
Boosting Promotion or Seasonal Items: If you have a holiday sale or a seasonal collection, you can set rules so that a search for generic terms will sprinkle in some of those promotional items. E.g., a search for “gifts” in December might show your holiday gift bundle as the first result.
Redirecting Certain Searches: For some queries, you might not want the standard product grid at all. For example, searching “store locator” or “shipping policy” might be better served by taking the user to an informational page. You can set up rules to handle these cases.
Banner or Content Integration: Some brands integrate marketing banners at the top of search results for certain keywords (e.g., searching “membership” could show a banner about your loyalty program). Just be careful that this augments rather than distracts from showing products.
Upselling and Cross-Selling: Like the Target DSLR example, consider showing higher-end alternatives or related items in results. Another case is showing accessories: a search for a phone could also display a popular phone case. This can increase the average order value.
Demoting Unprofitable or Low-Stock Items: Conversely, you might push products that are nearly out of stock lower down, or hide items with low margins in favor of ones with better margins (as long as relevance to the query is still maintained).
These kinds of rules can be implemented via your search engine’s admin (if supported) or with some custom logic. The idea is to merge merchandising strategy with search intent. When done right, it increases conversion and often boosts the basket size, because you’re showing customers items in the search results that you want them to see (and that they are likely interested in).
Identify your top 10–20 search queries (especially category-level terms like “shoes”, “skincare”, etc.) and decide if any special merchandising would make sense for each. Then use your search solution’s features to create those boosts or redirects. Monitor the impact on click-through and sales for those queries and adjust as needed.
One advanced tactic is incorporating personalization into search. This means the results take into account the individual user’s behavior or profile. For example, if a returning customer typically buys men’s clothing, a search for “jackets” might show men’s jackets first, whereas a different user might see women’s jackets.
Personalization can also use browsing history (e.g., if you viewed electronics, a search for “apple” might prioritize electronics over fruit). If you can implement even basic personalization, it can set your UX apart. Some AI-driven search engines will do this out of the box, or you can segment customers (like by gender preference if known, or by past purchases) and tweak results accordingly.
Evaluate if your current platform supports personalized search ranking. If not, consider whether the investment in a more advanced solution is justified by your scale – for many mid-sized DTC brands, it can be. Start small, perhaps by personalizing results for logged-in users vs. new visitors, and see if it lifts conversion.
Invest in AI-Powered Search Technology
Many of the above tactics – from autocomplete and typo tolerance to personalized, intent-based results – are made much easier by modern AI-powered site search solutions. While we won’t endorse a specific tool here, it’s worth noting that the field of site search has evolved rapidly. AI and machine learning can now interpret natural language queries, learn from user behavior to improve relevance, and even handle things like voice or visual search.
If your current search platform is outdated or your CMS’s built-in search is too basic, upgrading to a dedicated tech partner can be a game-changer. These solutions come with features like NLP (natural language processing) that understands queries in plain English (e.g., a query like “best camera under $500” could actually be understood and filtered accordingly), vector search for semantic matching (so “running sneakers” matches “jogging shoes” even if the exact word isn’t present). Crucially, they save your team the effort of reinventing the wheel – you get enterprise-grade search without having to build it all in-house.
Many DTC brands find that outsourcing search to a specialized provider yields a quick ROI. In short, better search = more sales, and AI is the enabler for “better” in many cases. Assess your site search’s current capabilities vs. what’s available in the market. If features like typo correction, synonyms, and dynamic ranking are lacking, it may be time to consider an upgrade. Even if budget is a concern, remember that the revenue uplift from improved search can be substantial (often in double-digit percentage increases), easily justifying the investment.
Conclusion
Optimizing your internal site search is one of the most practical, high-ROI moves a DTC brand can make to recover lost ecommerce sales. It requires some focus and possibly new tools, but the payoff is clear: more of your hard-won site visitors will convert into buyers. The impact on revenue can be significant. You’ll reduce bounce rates from search pages, increase add-to-cart and conversion rates, and likely see overall sales lift as more visitors find what they need. Importantly, you’ll also be delivering a better customer experience, which improves your brand reputation in the long run.
Localization isn't just translation. It's about tuning the entire experience—visually, functionally, and emotionally—to meet the expectations of users in a specific market.
What to Do
Market Examples
Language and tone
Transcreate, not just translate. Adapt idioms and tone to local speech.
Japan: Modest, formal language. Brazil: Friendly and casual.
Currency and pricing
Use local currency and format. Show total costs upfront.
SEA: Price sensitivity demands clarity on hidden fees.
Visual density and layout
Align with cultural expectations of content density.
Localizing UX Without Burning the Whole Design System
For global brands nervous about messing with their design systems, here’s a clear, practical way to tackle localization without breaking everything apart:
Step 1: Start with high-impact markets
Not every market needs full localization—but some absolutely do. Start by zeroing in on countries where your ecommerce traffic is solid, but conversions lag noticeably. These are the opportunities hiding in plain sight: visitors already show interest, but friction prevents them from converting. Here’s how to identify high-impact markets:
High traffic but low conversion rates: These markets are already aware of your brand but are abandoning before purchase.
Significant cultural or infrastructural distance: Markets that differ substantially from your home base (e.g., U.S. vs. Southeast Asia, or Western Europe vs. the Middle East) often require interface, language, or payment adaptations.
Mobile-first regions with weak desktop performance: In places like India, Indonesia, and Nigeria, shoppers need mobile-optimized flows with localized expectations built in.
Before overhauling your entire storefront, identify the specific UX elements that are breaking the experience for local users. Cart abandonment typically doesn’t stem from a single issue—it’s the cumulative effect of several small mismatches. Focus your localization efforts on these high-friction points first:
Payment methods: Are you supporting the region’s trusted options? In Germany, users expect options like Sofort or PayPal. In India, UPI and Cash on Delivery are deal-breakers. If you’re asking for a credit card in a market where bank transfers dominate, you’ve already lost the sale.
Language clarity: Many brands rely on auto-translation, which creates clunky, sometimes nonsensical experiences. Local shoppers instantly spot unnatural phrasing. Instead, copy should be transcreated to reflect local idioms, tone, and fluency.
Trust signals: Is the shopper seeing security icons and reviews they recognize? A McAfee badge might mean little in Thailand, whereas a logo from a local e-wallet or government-backed guarantee holds more weight.
Shipping logic and visibility: Is delivery framed in a way that matches local expectations? Showing "3-day shipping" may set the wrong expectation if fulfillment partners regularly delay in that region. Also, hiding final shipping fees until checkout is a conversion killer in markets that are price sensitive.
Assumptions don’t just cost you conversions—they distort your entire optimization strategy. The way people interact with ecommerce experiences is heavily shaped by their cultural context, native language, trust norms, and purchasing behaviors.
That’s why localized A/B testing is more than a refinement tactic—it’s a foundational strategy. Instead of relying on broad-stroke design patterns that perform well globally, run region-specific tests designed to answer: What works for this audience, in this market, on this device?
Key elements to localize and test:
CTA language and tone: Direct CTAs like “Buy Now” might feel aggressive in conservative markets. Try alternatives like “Order Securely,” “View Options,” or “Continue.” Also test placement—above the fold vs. end-of-scroll—and button size or shape.
Urgency vs. reassurance: Cultures differ on what motivates action. Urgent messages like “Only 2 Left!” might drive clicks in the U.S., but underperform in Japan, where subtle, low-pressure cues tend to build trust more effectively.
Discount and promotion display: Test whether percent-based discounts (e.g., 20% off) perform better than absolute savings (e.g., $15 off) in a given market. Time-based promos vs. product bundling may also vary in effectiveness.
Form complexity and order: Test fewer form fields, optional guest checkout, or local auto-fill support. Even the order of first name vs. last name can be a point of confusion depending on cultural norms.
Layout density: Some regions (like Japan or India) prefer information-rich screens, while others (like Sweden or the U.K.) prefer minimal, distraction-free flows. Let the data—not aesthetics—guide the layout.
A lot of brands measure user experience success using broad, global benchmarks. But here’s the thing: global averages can hide local pain points. If your conversion rate is 2% in the U.S. but only 0.3% in Indonesia, you’ve got to ask—what’s really going on? Is the product not resonating, or is the user experience just not clicking for that market?
The answer often lies in the UX. Design decisions that feel intuitive in one region can feel confusing or frustrating in another. That’s why it’s important to go beyond one-size-fits-all metrics and start looking at localized KPIs. These give you a clearer view of what’s actually happening on the ground.
Some key UX signals to track by market:
Cart-to-checkout initiation rate (by country): Are users adding items but not even starting the checkout flow? That’s a red flag for friction in the transition.
Payment method drop-off rate: If people are dropping off at the payment screen, it might be because their preferred method isn’t there—or isn’t presented in a way that feels trustworthy or familiar.
Bounce rate from localized product pages (PDPs): Are local users landing on your product pages and immediately leaving? This could point to language tone, layout expectations, or even missing cultural context.
Time to complete checkout (across locales): A longer-than-average checkout time in certain countries could hint at confusing flows, too many form fields, or clunky translations.
Scaling localization used to feel like a massive lift—tons of manual tweaks, endless testing, and a risk of breaking your design system. But AI is changing the game. Smart systems can now help you localize without all the heavy lifting.
Here’s how AI makes it smoother:
Dynamic interfaces by region: Based on a user’s IP or profile, your site can serve up different layouts, flows, or even button styles that align better with regional expectations.
Smarter payment options: AI can predict and surface the most relevant payment methods for each shopper—so users in Brazil see Pix, while shoppers in Germany might get Klarna or direct debit.
Behavior-based messaging: Instead of blasting the same CTA everywhere, AI can tailor language and tone based on local browsing patterns, device types, or even how price-sensitive a user seems.
This isn’t just personalization—it’s geo-adaptation. And it’s the future of high-converting retail tech. Contact us to know more.
Final Thought
Cart abandonment isn’t always a problem of intent. Often, it’s a problem of misalignment between the shopper’s expectations and the UX they’re handed. Brands willing to localize the final yards of the purchase journey—not just the marketing funnel—stand to recapture millions in lost revenue.